6 Best Protein Bars of 2017: Our Tested Reviews

By Ryan Bucki / February 25, 2017

Finding the right protein bar can be extremely difficult. This is because there are so many selections on the market today. So many companies are attempting to join in on the fun of the protein bar market by making a product and slapping "protein bar" on the packaging. This is enough to fool the everyday consumer, but not us. We refuse to stand by and let you select the wrong "protein bar" when you buy your goods online or inside a retail outlet.

As human beings we have a natural sweet tooth. Many humans appease this sweet tooth with the use of a candy bar like a Twix or a Snickers bar. There are so many other healthy alternatives that can take care of that sweet tooth while promoting a healthy way of life and muscle gains. Spoiler alert: it's not a candy bar, it's a high quality protein bar.

The Best Protein Bar Reviews: 2017 Comparison Table

Ranking

Protein Bar

Ingredients & Features

Price

#1

OhYeah! ONE Bar Best of Protein Bar

OhYeah! ONE Bar

  • 5g of NET Carbs
  • Protein Isolate Based
  • 13 Different Flavors

Lowest Price

More Info

#2

QUEST Bar Top Protein Bar

Quest Nutrition QUEST Bar

  • 3g of NET Carbs
  • Protein Isolate Based
  • Over 20 Different Flavors

Lowest Price

More Info

#3

ProSupps MyBar Top Rated Protein Bar

ProSupps MyBar

  • Whey Protein Blend
  • Zero Sugar Alcohol
  • Baked Bar

Lowest Price

More Info

#4

Optimum Nutrition Cake Bites Top Rated Protein Bar

Optimum Nutrition Cake Bites

  • Best Tasting
  • Bite Size (3 Per Package)
  • Great Value

Lowest Price

More Info

#5

FITCrunch Bar Top Rated Protein Bar

Chef Robert Irvine's Fit Crunch Bar

  • 30g of Protein Per Bar
  • 9g Of Net Carbs
  • Whey Protein Based

Lowest Price

More Info

#6

Combat Crunch Bars Top Rated Protein Bar

MusclePharm Combat Crunch Bar

  • Baked Bar
  • Great Tasting
  • Chocolate Coated

Lowest Price

More Info

The Problem

One of the biggest issues facing the protein bar market is what we already described above. So many consumer package goods companies are creating bars, loading it with under quality protein, putting 20g of protein on the label and people just assume it is good. That is not the case.

Not every protein bar is good for you. Not all protein bars should be treated equal. Walk into a gas station and look at the protein bars. They are camouflaged in with the candy bars. We don't mean this in the way that they are put next to the candy bars, but the fact that a lot of these "protein bars" are actual candy bars!

Don't waste your time and your health by looking up non-quality protein bars. Fitness Informant has complied a comprehensive list of the the six best protein bars on the market today! Stop being fooled. It's time to be educated on the world of the best protein bars.

We have taken the liberty to help you find your next protein bar. This is our list of the top six protein bars on the market. You will not find a more honest, better compiled list than ours.


Our Testing Process

We examined four different areas of each protein bar when we compiled our rankings:

  • Ingredients (Macros included)
  • Taste
  • Texture
  • Value

Please Note: Many of the top 10 protein bar lists you find online are written by content writers with no in-gym or supplement experience who are paid by the word count to write an article for a website trying to generate money. These lists are influenced by brands who pay for placement. Other lists are written by online retailers who will place the higher margin items at the top of their list.

The following products on our best of list were used by the author of this article, Fitness Informant's President Ryan Bucki. He personally tested each protein bar.

Stop relying on faulty information that is influenced by outside writers and money. This list is the real deal. We don't steer you wrong. Be Informed. Live Fit.

Fitness Informant Guarantee on Why Our Reviews are Legitimate

We just want to remind you that these products were personally tested by Fitness Informant's President Ryan Bucki. We do not rely on content writers to write our reviews.

Fitness Informant prides itself on being 100% honest with our reviews. We will not be influenced by outsiders. You can trust in us that we are providing you with the absolute accurate truth in our reviews of protein bars. 

Read More About Us​


The Top 6 Protein Bars are:

 

#6

MusclePharm Combat Crunch Bar

Combat Crunch Bars #6 Rated Protein Bar

Combat Crunch Bars from MusclePharm are great protein bars from a reputable sports nutrition company. Combat Crunch Bars were the first protein bar to be baked. This provided a much needed shake up in the protein bar market. MusclePharm capitalized on a weak point in the protein bar market to take market share away from competitors. By leveraging a strong brand and a great tasting protein bar, Combat Crunch Bars became a popular choice among those in the fitness community.

Overview

Who Makes It: MusclePharm is a strong recognizable brand in the sports nutrition industry. They have marketing that is second to none. The bright green colors of their packaging is sure to always catch your eye. On top of that they worked with some of the worlds most premier athletes including Arnold Schwarzenegger, Tiger Woods, Shawn Merriman and more to put their name on the map. Today, MusclePharm is one of the most recognizable brands in the industry.

Combat Crunch Bar Label

Combat Crunch Bars contain 20g of protein per protein bar. Combat Crunch Bars utilize protein isolates (whey protein isolate and milk protein isolate) as their main source of protein. This bar contains whey and casein protein. The Combat Crunch Bar does contain 15g of NET carbs (carbohydrates less fibers less sugar alcohols) but a very limited amount of sugar alcohol for those who are sensitive to it. With 7g of fat the Combat Crunch Bars have a pseudo macro friendly profile for those who count their macros. A tad higher on the carbs than other bars, this is still a great profile.

What's In It: one bar contains:

  • 20g Protein - Whey Protein Isolate and Milk Protein Isolates; isolates prove to absorb more into your system
  • 15g NET Carbs - With 12g of Dietary Fibers and 1g of Sugar Alcohols this reduces the overall carbs from 28g to 15g.
  • 7g of Fat - Macro friendly
  • Chocolate Chunks - appeases to your sweet tooth

Bottom Line: Combat Crunch Bars are a solid protein bar for those who are serious about their health and wellness. With a great flavor to tag along with a baked texture, the Combat Crunch Bar provides a much needed change from the traditional protein bar market.

Ingredients
Taste
Texture
Value
75 %
Overall Score
Highlights
  • 20g Protein
  • 15g NET Carbs
  • Baked Bars
  • Great Taste
  • Utilizes Protein Isolates
  • 9 Different Flavors

Full Combat Crunch Bar Review

Combat Crunch Bars #6 Rated Protein Bar

#5

Chef Robert Irvine's FIT Crunch Bar

FITCrunch Bar #5 Rated Protein Bar

FIT Crunch Bars from Chef Robert Irvine are awesome protein bars from someone who really has not had a huge place in the protein bar or sports nutrition industry. FIT Crunch Bars are larger than your typical protein bar which means you will also get more protein per bar than the other protein bars. With that also comes a higher amount of calories and fats, but it does not come at the cost of a higher amount of carbs. FIT Crunch Bars have a place in the industry and they are here to stay due to their ingredients, taste, texture and value.

Overview

Who Makes It: Chef Robert Irvine is famous for his shows on the Food Network. He’s been in episodes of Chopped, Beat Booby Flay and others. Robert Irvine is also a fitness enthusiast who used his culinary knowledge to enter into the protein bar market.

FIT CRUNCH Label

The nice thing about FIT Crunch Bars being made by a culinary expert is he knows high quality ingredients. FIT Crunch Bars utilizes whey protein as the main source of protein in these bars. While most use milk proteins (80% casein and 20% whey) FIT Crunch uses only whey protein. At 30g of protein per bar you are getting one of the highest sources of protein in a single protein bar. Sure, you get 16g of fat per bar but you are only getting 9g of NET carbs per bar making the FIT Crunch Bar macro friendly for those looking for more protein in their diets.

What's In It: one bar contains:

  • 30g Protein - whey protein isolate and whey protein concentrate only; a higher quality protein bar
  • 9g NET Carbs - due to the use of dietary fibers and sugar alcohols this brings the bar down from 27g of carbohydrates to only 9g of NET carbs
  • 380 Calories - due to the high calories in this bar this can be used as a good meal replacement bar or a supplement to a diet struggling to get enough calories (bulking)
  • 8g Saturated Fats - these are the "good" fats that you need and want in your diet

Bottom Line: FIT Crunch Bars deserve a place in the protein bar game. They are baked and taste great! They have more protein per bar than the competition. These are perfect for those who are looking to add more protein and calories to their diet.

Ingredients
Taste
Texture
Value
75 %
Overall Score
Highlights
  • 30g of Protein
  • Whey Protein Isolate & Whey Protein Concentrate Main Source
  • 5 Different Flavors
  • 380 Calories for Meal Replacement
  • Great Taste
  • Soft Texture

Full FIT Crunch Bar Review

FITCrunch Bar #5 Rated Protein Bar

#4

Optimum Nutrition Cake Bites

Optimum Nutrition Cake Bites #4 Rated Protein Bar

Cake Bites by Optimum Nutrition are one of the best tasting protein bars that we've ever tried. What is also unique about them is they come in a pack of three instead of a whole bar so they can be easily shared with your swole mates. As a fairly new protein bar on the market it is proven to be tough to keep these on the shelves as people are flocking to buy them. They are different than your typical protein bar but in a very good way. The taste and texture will make your eyes light us as you will truly believe you are eating desert.

Overview

Who Makes It: Optimum Nutrition is probably the most well known brand and the biggest brand in the sports nutrition industry. They win awards at the Olympia each year for their protein through BodyBuilding.com. They make everything under the sun in this industry and have their finger on the pulse of everything.

Optimum Nutrition Cake Bites Label

Optimum Nutrition Cake Bites purposely target your taste buds and not nessessarily with the use of high quality ingredients. They do utilize milk protein concentrate, whey protein isolate and milk protein isolate as the main protein source. You are getting 20g of protein per package is what we've come to expect from a protein bar. It is macro friendly with only 7g of fats but it does contain 25g of carbs which can prove to be an issue. This is the sacrifice they made when making this great tasting protein bar! They truly wanted you to feel like you were eating cake.

What's In It: one bar contains:

  • 20g Protein - utilizes milk protein concentrate (80% casein and 20% whey), whey protein isolate and milk protein isolate. A lot of casein in the protein blend but you do need to feed your body throughout the day.
  • 7g Fat - very limited amount of fat in an amazing tasting protein bar (you'd think there was so much more) and it has 4g of the good saturated fats
  • 25g NET Carbs - this bar does not utilize sugar alcohols which is why the taste is superior to other bars but it does affect the NET carbs as this is on the higher end of protein bars
  • 5g Sugar - with how good this tastes you'd imagine that this is higher, so for this awesome tasting protein bar the limited sugar is good
  • 3 Cake Bites - allows you to do portion control if you want to limit your carb intake and it makes it easy to share with swolemates

Bottom Line: Cake Bites do contain more carbs than your traditional protein bar, but they taste amazing. We talked about how not all protein bars are good for you, well this protein bar tastes like it is bad for you but based on the ingredients used it is not. The only issue you might have is if you're limiting your carb intake. Otherwise this protein bar is an awesome addition to this market and we would suggest that everyone needs to have these. You truly can have your cake and eat it too...guilt free and at a great price!

Ingredients
Taste
Texture
Value
80 %
Overall Score
Highlights
  • Best Tasting Protein Bar
  • 20g of Protein per Package
  • Only 7g of Fat
  • 3 Cake Bites per Package
  • 3 Amazing Flavors
  • Amazing Value

View our full Cake Bites Review

Optimum Nutrition Cake Bites #4 Rated Protein Bar

#3

ProSupps MyBar

ProSupps MyBar #3 Rated Protein Bar

MyBars from ProSupps are another baked protein bar added into the protein bar game but distinguishes itself from the other baked bars by being better tasting with a better texture. MyBar was highly anticipated by the market because of beta tests that proved that they would be something special. They are able to utilize a chocolate coating to make you feel like you're eating a candy bar but the reality is you're eating a high quality protein bar!

Overview

Who Makes It: ProSupps is a reputable sports nutrition brand most famous for their pre-workout Mr. Hyde. However, ProSupps makes many different products in the industry including protein powder, aminos, vitamins, fat burners and more.

ProSupps MyBar Label

MyBar from ProSupps utilizes the best protein blend you can have in a protein bar: whey protein isolate and whey protein concentrate. Unlike other bars who utilize milk protein as their primary source, MyBar uses the best. The MyBar does contain a higher amount of carbs but that is due to the fact that they do not rely on sugar alcohols which positively affects the taste. At 15g of NET carbs and 10g of fats this is a little on the higher side of a macro friendly diet, but it has to be to give us the taste we get and the texture we desire. 

What's In It: one bar contains:

  • 20g Protein - whey protein isolate and whey protein concentrate is the primary protein source meaning you are getting a high quality protein bar
  • 16g NET Carbs - higher than a majority of protein bars on the market but MyBar does not rely on the usage of sugar alcohols to reduce the NET carbs thus making ti better tasting and does not affect those who have issue with sugar alcohols
  • 10g Fat - we would typically see around 7g here on a protein bar but the MyBar does contain 5g of saturated fats which are good for you
  • Chocolate Coating - makes you feel like you are having a desert aka cheat meal but you're really not

Bottom Line: MyBar from ProSupps is a special protein bar. It is baked which provides better texture and taste. All this while using high quality protein as the main protein source. Other baked bars in this category typically use a lower quality protein or do not taste as good. MyBar is the best baked protein bar we've ever tried.

Ingredients
Taste
Texture
Value
80 %
Overall Score
Highlights
  • Best Baked Protein Bar
  • 20g High Quality Protein
  • Chocolate Coating
  • Superior Texture
  • Limited Sugar Alcohols
  • 4 Awesome Flavors

View our MyBar Review

ProSupps MyBar #3 Rated Protein Bar

#2

Quest Nutrition QUEST Bar

QUEST Bar #2 Rated Protein Bar

QUEST Bars from Quest Nutrition revolutionized the protein bar game. QUEST Bars were the first protein bar introduced to the market to gain popularity for being different in a very good way. Traditionally protein bars tasted dry, were hard to chew and the only reason they were consumed is because we were told they were better for us. QUEST Bars were consumed because they tasted good, had a better texture and were truly good for us.

Overview

Who Makes It: Quest Nutrition revolutionized the protein bar game. They were the first brand since PowerBar to come out as a protein bar only company to become the leader in the industry. After a change in formula put the company at risk, Quest went back to their original formula to regain market share. Today you can find their products in convenience stores nation-wide. They also make protein chips, breakfast bars, pasta and protein powders.

Quest Protein Bar Label

QUEST Bars are the most macro friendly protein bar on the market today. With the use of sugar alcohols and dietary fibers they are able to have a protein bar of only 3g of NET Carbs. All this while still giving us 21g of protein and only 8g of fat. They also use protein isolates as their main protein source for faster absorption into our system. QUEST Bars did it right when sourcing their ingredients and relied heavily on their ingredient profile to win customers over. Their taste and texture are good too which seems surprising given the lower amount of fats and carbs.

What's In It: one bar contains:

  • 3g NET Carbs - these active carbs are so low because of the use of sugar alcohols and dietary fibers taking the carbohydrates from 21g to 3g
  • 21g Protein - a solid amount of protein in this bar utilizing protein isolates (whey protein isolate and milk protein isolate)
  • 8g Fat - macro friendly protein bar that tastes good while limiting your fats; you also get 3g of saturated fats which are good for you
  • Prebiotic Fibers - reduces your active carb level making it macro friendly
  • 190 Calories - one of the lowest calorie protein bars on the market

Bottom Line: QUEST Bars have been the industry leader for a long time and we can see why. They use high quality ingredients while making a good tasting, decent textured protein bar that is macro friendly at a good price. These are readily available in gas stations throughout the nation (USA) and are a solid choice to buy while you're on the run. They have over 20 flavors to choose from, no other protein bar company has that.

Ingredients
Taste
Texture
Value
80 %
Overall Score
Highlights
  • 3g NET Carbs
  • 21g Quality Protein
  • Over 20 Flavors
  • Macro Friendly
  • Only 8g of Fat
  • Available Everywhere

View our Full QUEST Bar Review

QUEST Bar #2 Rated Protein Bar

#1

OhYeah! ONE Bar

OhYeah! ONE Bar #1 Rated Protein Bars

OhYeah! ONE Bar by ISS Research gained popularity on QUEST Bars when Quest Nutrition changed their formulation on their original QUEST Bar (they have since gone back to the original formulation due to complaints). There was room for a new player in the protein bar space and OhYeah! ONE Bar capitalized by creating our top rated protein bar. It utilizes a high quality ingredient profile while staying macro friend. It gives us superior taste and texture compared to others and they don't even inflate the price!

Overview

Who Makes It: ISS Research makes a lot of different products for the sports nutrition industry. They do brand most of their products under the OhYeah! umbrella but they also carry other items like Victory Bars which are very popular.

OhYeah! ONE Protein Bar Label

OhYeah! ONE Bar tops our list because they were able to make a great tasting protein bar with an awesome texture all while maintaining quality ingredients and being macro friendly. ONE Bars contain only 5g of NET carbs and 7g of fats. They are able to keep carbs low and fats even lower. ONE Bars also contain 21g of protein from whey protein isolate and milk protein isolates, a high quality protein blend. These bars are also gluten free which is big in the fitness community. One area of highlight is the sodium count is also really low on these compared to others.

What's In It: one contains:

  • 21g Protein - high quality protein isolates (whey protein isolate and milk protein isolate) provides for better absorption by our bodies
  • 5g NET Carbs - still macro friendly by using sugar alcohols and dietary fibers to reduce carbohydrates from 24g to 5g
  • 7g Fat - a low fat total keeps this bar macro friendly while still providing superior taste
  • 140mg Sodium - one of the lowest sodium content bars available
  • Tasty Coating - whether it is chocolate or vanilla you are eating a bar that makes you think you are having desert

Bottom Line: OhYeah! ONE Bars were able to secure our #1 spot because they use high quality ingredients while creating a macro friendly bar that is great tasting, with superior texture and at a great value. They give you everything you want in a protein bar that makes you realize you never need to eat another candy bar in your life. ONE Bars were able to capitalize on what QUEST Bars did in terms of ingredient quality and macro compliance while creating a better tasting protein bar.

Ingredients
Taste
Texture
Value
85 %
Overall Score
Highlights
  • 21g Quality Protein
  • 5g NET Carbs
  • 7g Fat
  • 13 Different Flavors
  • Great Taste
  • Superior Texture

View our full ONE Bar Review

OhYeah! ONE Bar #1 Rated Protein Bars

Final Takeaways

We understand your urge to select a candy bar over a protein bar. We understand this because many of you choose a protein bar that is an actual candy bar. It is important to educate yourself on the quality of protein used in the making of a protein bar and what to avoid. We understand that most of you will not do that. That is why we provided this list to you.

All protein bars are not created equally. Some protein bars are made with the best of intensions. These are made with high quality ingredients, macro friendly profiles, and with taste and texture in mind. While others are made with only one thing in mind: profit. You should have one thing in mind: your health. 

The next time you are online searching for protein bars or at a retailer browsing the shelves be sure to buy a protein bar that is on this list. If you cannot find one that's on this list then don't default to a candy bar "protein bar." Turn the package over and look at the ingredient panel. Is it macro friendly? Does it use whey proteins? At the end of the day you want to favor something that is better for you, even if you have to sacrifice taste. The best thing about this list is you don't have to sacrifice anything. You get to promote your health while digesting the highest quality, best tasting protein bars on the market today.

Be Informed. Live Fit.

Leave a comment: